Can "chocolate" exist without cacao? The sweet future with a slightly bitter reality

Can "chocolate" exist without cacao? The sweet future with a slightly bitter reality

1. "The Day Chocolate Becomes a Luxury" Has Already Begun

Chocolate used to be a "sweet treat you could buy anytime." However, in recent years, this assumption has begun to crumble. The reasons are not simple. Poor harvests due to climate change, diseases, aging farms, land use and deforestation issues, and fluctuations in international market prices. As a result, manufacturers, confectioners, and consumers are facing the reality that "the usual taste is no longer available at the usual price."


This has led to a slightly provocative idea emerging.
"Can we make something 'chocolate-like' without using cocoa beans?"
This question is not merely about finding a substitute. It is an attempt to redesign the chocolate supply structure itself through an "alternative route."


2. Where Does the "Chocolate Essence" Come From?

When you break down the allure of chocolate, it roughly boils down to three elements.

  • Aroma (nutty, caramel, fruity, and sometimes smoky notes derived from roasting)

  • Flavor (balance of bitterness, acidity, and sweetness)

  • Texture (the "snap" when it breaks, smooth mouthfeel, and how it melts at body temperature)


Interestingly, many of these elements are not necessarily exclusive to cocoa beans but are significantly influenced by fermentation, roasting, and fat content design.


Therefore, developers of alternative chocolates aim not to "replace" cocoa itself but to engineer the chocolate experience (aroma, flavor, texture).


3. The "Three Routes" of Alternative Chocolate

There are broadly three directions for "chocolate alternatives" that do not use cocoa.


Route A: Create "chocolate aroma" by fermenting and roasting plant-based ingredients

A representative example is the type that creates chocolate flavor by fermenting and roasting sunflower seeds. Planet A Foods' ChoViva belongs to this category, with the core idea of transplanting the "fermentation → roasting" framework of traditional chocolate making to alternative ingredients.


The aim is to reduce dependence on tropical cocoa, lowering supply risks and environmental impact. In addition to flavor reproducibility, being "easy to handle" as a B2B (confectionery ingredient) is also important.


Route B: Create "similarity" using by-products and upcycled materials

There are examples of using by-products from other industries, such as grape seeds, as a roasted base. Voyage Foods is known for its approach of targeting cocoa flavor and functionality (processing suitability) through a combination of ingredients. Investments in facilities and partnerships for large-scale production are also underway.


Route C: Cultivate cocoa "cells" to create cocoa as a component

Another direction is to cultivate cocoa-derived cells to obtain cocoa components without using cocoa beans themselves. Companies like California Cultured have been discussing the idea of creating something "close to cocoa" through cell cultivation (so-called bio-manufacturing).


If this route becomes a reality, "factory production of cocoa components" not bound by origin or climate will become visible. However, there are significant hurdles such as regulations, costs, scale, and consumer sentiment.


4. The Biggest Challenge is "Cocoa Butter" — Can the Melting Sensation Be Engineered?

The battleground for alternative chocolate is not just aroma. Rather, what many people ultimately judge is the melting sensation.
The sensation of chocolate melting at body temperature and disappearing smoothly on the tongue is mainly governed by the melting point design of the fats. Here, the uniqueness of cocoa butter stands as a barrier.


Therefore, in alternative chocolate, plant oils and fats (shea butter, palm, and other plant-based fats) are blended to adjust the melting and solidifying properties. This often leads to the impression of "delicious but somehow different." While engineers can "mimic," consumers compare it to the "taste of memory."


5. Reactions on Social Media: "It's Great" vs. "That's Not Chocolate"

What makes this field interesting is that reactions on social media tend to be polarized. In fact, around a post covered by CNN about Prefer (a Singapore startup), there are voices of expectation as a "solution to the soaring chocolate prices" and voices of skepticism asking, "What about the taste? Additives? Isn't it ultimately processed food?"


Here, we organize typical social media reactions by points of discussion.


A) Welcome and Expectation: "Considering the reality of climate and prices, more options are better"

  • "If we can achieve the same satisfaction, I'd choose the option that reduces deforestation and supply uncertainty."

  • "If chocolate becomes a luxury, I'd rather have alternatives to bring it back to everyday life."

The feeling of being "struggling with both price and environment" strengthens this stance.


B) Skepticism: "Isn't that just 'something with a chocolate flavor'?"

  • "If you're not using cocoa, you should change the name too."

  • "Only part of the aroma can be replicated. The aftertaste and complexity might become something else."


There is a sense of seeking the "story of the origin" in chocolate, similar to wine and coffee. Those who have loved chocolate as a luxury item tend to resist substitution.


C) Realists: "It depends on the use"

  • "If you're eating it as a chocolate bar, the real thing is better. But for baked goods, alternatives can work."

  • "For cookie or ice cream coatings, the texture is largely determined by the blend anyway."


This stance might be the strongest in the food industry. Alternative chocolate as a B2B ingredient can easily enter as "part of a mix."

6. After "Ethical Chocolate," Is It "Post-Cocoa"?

Until now, "good chocolate" has been improved based on cocoa, focusing on fair trade, traceability, and farmer support. But now, the discussion is advancing to the next stage.


Whether to save cocoa or to move away from cocoa.


It's not about which is right. While livelihoods depend on the cocoa industry, if the balance of supply and demand continues to collapse globally, the burden on consumers and farmers will simultaneously increase. Alternative chocolate may function as a "bypass road" to ease that congestion.


7. The One Question That Remains

In the end, a very simple question remains.

"Is it delicious?"


Sustainability, price stability, and increased supply—all are important. But chocolate won't sell on righteousness alone. Without the "happiness" you feel the moment it enters your mouth, it won't last.


If alternative chocolate truly gains acceptance, it will be when it starts being loved as a new delicacy that people say "I like this", rather than as a "substitute to endure."


And that future might come sooner than expected. As the reality of cocoa changes, so too will the form of sweets. The next chapter of chocolate begins not with beans, but with fermentation tanks, roasting machines, and the memories of our tongues.


Sources

Related Articles