Muscle Mass" Influences Health"> Muscle Mass" Influences Health | ukiyo journal - 日本と世界をつなぐ新しいニュースメディア">
The Importance of Aging: How the Same Weight Can Make You a Different Person. Why "Muscle Strength > Muscle Mass" Influences Health

The Importance of Aging: How the Same Weight Can Make You a Different Person. Why "Muscle Strength > Muscle Mass" Influences Health

1) "Muscle Mass" or "Muscle Strength"? — The Starting Point of the Discussion

When it comes to strength training, the idea of "increasing muscle" and "building a bigger body" often takes precedence. However, in recent years, from the perspective of health and independence (fall prevention, climbing stairs, carrying luggage, maintaining posture), the argument that "how much strength you can exert = muscle strength" is more important than the visible muscle mass has been gaining traction.


The background is simple. The troubles of daily life arise more from "not being able to exert strength," "not being able to move quickly," or "not being able to brace oneself" rather than "having less muscle." In other words, the "output" rather than the "size" of muscles determines the quality of life.


2) Why Muscle Strength Declines More Easily Than Muscle Mass: The Concept of "Muscle Quality"

Muscle strength seems to be proportional to muscle mass. But in reality, there are strong and weak people with the same muscle mass. This is where the concept of "muscle quality" comes into play.


Muscle strength involves not only the muscles themselves but also factors such as

  • how efficiently nerves can recruit muscles (recruitment rate, timing)

  • the nature of muscle fibers (ratio of fast-twitch to slow-twitch)

  • the "internal state" such as fat infiltration within the muscles

  • the stiffness, range of motion, and pain in joints and tendons
    These elements are involved.


With aging, muscle mass decreases, but more significantly, the "coordination between nerves and muscles" and "quality" decline, which can result in muscle strength dropping first. Therefore, merely "efforts to increase muscle" may not make daily activities as easy as expected.

3) If Measuring Muscle Strength, Focus on "Functional Indicators" Rather Than "Appearance"

A commonly used indicator in the health context is grip strength. Grip strength is said to reflect not only "hand strength" but also the overall condition of the body, frequently appearing as a risk indicator in epidemiological studies. Of course, grip strength alone cannot tell the whole story, but it symbolizes the shift from looking at "muscle mass" to "output and function."


Additionally, in practical terms,

  • whether one can stand up smoothly from a chair

  • whether one can brace themselves when stumbling

  • whether one can lift their legs on stairs

  • whether one can carry luggage while walking
    These "tests of daily activities" remind us of the purpose of body building.

4) Is Strength Training About "Weight" or "Effort"? — The Reality That "Results Differ Even for the Same Person"

Muscle strength and muscle mass generally tend to grow together. However, even with the same regimen, individual differences arise, such as "getting stronger but not bigger" or "getting bigger but not much stronger." Factors such as genetics, experience, diet, sleep, and daily activity levels are involved.


Recent studies and explanations repeatedly emphasize the importance of "properly fatiguing the targeted muscles" and "adapting to a sustainable form" rather than the size of the weight. It aligns with the field experience that it's more effective to "properly engage" within a range where the form does not break down, rather than forcing high weights on those with joint concerns.


5) And the Often Overlooked Third Element: "Power (Exerting Force Quickly)"

As the discussion on "muscle strength" progresses, "power" emerges next. Power is "force × speed." Even with the same force, the faster it can be exerted, the higher the power.


When about to fall, what is needed is the ability to "brace instantly" rather than slowly exerting maximum muscle strength. This could be the next update in "strength training." However, the faster the speed, the more likely the form is to break down, and the burden on joints and tendons increases. A phased approach is essential.


6) Reactions on Social Media: Agreement and Criticism Simultaneously Emerged

In the social media (mainly senior fitness community) where this article's theme was shared, reactions were largely divided into three.


Reaction A: Supporters "Strength in Life Over Appearance"
"Training not to show muscles, but to be able to move."
Comments like these resonate more with those who have been training for a long time. Especially, the realization of a "body that doesn't get injured" and "a body that recovers quickly" is often expressed.


Reaction B: Realists "In the End, Muscle Mass Is Necessary, Right?"
On the other hand, there are many calm criticisms like "If you train muscle strength, muscles will also increase" and "It's wrong to promote just one side." In reality, muscle mass is also related to metabolism, body temperature maintenance, and "reserve power" during illness or hospitalization, so the feeling that completely discarding "mass" is reckless is understandable.


Reaction C: Cautious "Isn't Speed Emphasis Dangerous?"
The debate heated up particularly around "training to move quickly (power)."


Concerns about "moving heavy objects quickly is dangerous" are countered with arguments like "the definition of 'heavy' is relative," "no one is saying to recklessly speed through 90% of 1RM," and "appropriate programs and techniques are prerequisites." In short, while power is important, introducing it incorrectly can be counterproductive — this tends to be a point of agreement both on social media and in the field.


7) So, How to Train? — A Practical Approach to "Prioritizing Muscle Strength"

From here, let's move away from the binary choice of "muscle mass or muscle strength" and organize "priorities" according to the purpose.


(1) If the Goal Is Fall Prevention and Independence: Leg Strength + Balance + Some Power

  • Squat types (standing up from a chair is also acceptable)

  • Hip hinge types (light deadlift movements, hip lifts, etc.)

  • Practicing standing on one leg, taking larger steps

  • Once comfortable, "stand up quickly with light load" / quickly place foot on step
    Starting "speed" from light load and safe movements is the standard practice.


(2) If Concerned About Health Check Numbers and Metabolism: Enlist the Help of Overall Muscle Mass
Muscle mass plays a significant role in metabolic functions such as blood sugar control. Even rotating the whole body twice a week can significantly change your lifestyle. In many cases, strength training also results in increased muscle mass.


(3) If You Also Want Appearance: Base on Muscle Strength + Volume for "Both"
Combine the axis of increasing strength (relatively high load, low to medium repetitions) with the axis of muscle hypertrophy (medium load, medium repetitions, total volume). The "both are important" faction on social media generally practices this compromise.

8) Conclusion: Muscles Are "Usable Currency" Rather Than "Savings"

Muscle mass is, so to speak, the body's asset. Muscle strength is the ability to "withdraw that asset when needed." And power is "the speed of withdrawal."
Rather than idolizing one, it's wise to rearrange priorities according to age and purpose.


The motto from today can be this.
"Muscles that can move" over "big muscles."
The first step is not flashy routines but ensuring effectiveness at a sustainable frequency without breaking form.


Source URL

Related Articles