Good news for both strength training enthusiasts and cardio fans: Is exercise more about "type" than "quantity"? The latest research on a "variety of movements" that contribute to longevity

Good news for both strength training enthusiasts and cardio fans: Is exercise more about "type" than "quantity"? The latest research on a "variety of movements" that contribute to longevity

"Let's exercise for health." This slogan has remained unchanged for decades. However, recently, the focus in discussions about exercise has gradually shifted. It's not just about "how much you do," but also "what kind you do." In other words, "exercise diversity" might be related to longevity—a study that's gaining attention suggests this possibility.

"Even with the same amount of exercise, there was a difference"

The topic of interest this time is an analysis based on a large-scale cohort study in the United States. The subjects were primarily adults in healthcare professions, who have been regularly recording their activity levels and lifestyle habits over a long period. The key point is that instead of simply adding up exercise time, the study took a cross-sectional view of different "types of movements" in daily life, such as walking, running, cycling, strength training, yoga, gardening, and climbing stairs.


The results were simple and striking. Even when comparing the same total amount of exercise, those with a variety of exercise types tended to have a lower risk of mortality. In other words, even among people who "move the same amount weekly," combining multiple movements rather than repeating the same routine was associated with better outcomes.


Why the "exercise buffet" works (hypothesis)

Why does variety work? Since the study is observational, it cannot definitively establish causation. However, there are several plausible hypotheses.


  1. Filling the body's "weak spots"
    Aerobic exercise benefits the heart and lungs, strength training benefits muscle mass and bones, flexibility exercises improve range of motion, and racket sports or dance enhance reflexes and balance—each targets different areas. If you focus on just one type, you may improve in one area but leave other functions behind. Diversity may help fill the "gaps in physical abilities."

  2. Less prone to injury or burnout
    Repeating the same movements can easily accumulate stress on joints and tendons. The combo of pain → rest → habit breakdown is common. By spreading out the activities, you also spread the load, making it easier to continue.

  3. Not getting bored = Continuation
    The greatest weapon for longevity is "continuation." On social media, voices saying "continuing without getting bored is ultimately the strongest" stand out. The more options you have to choose from based on your mood, the weather, or your busy schedule, the easier it is for exercise to become integrated into your life.

A realistic answer to "Which exercise is good?"

In the study, walking was the most frequent activity. Walking, climbing stairs, strength training, racket sports, rowing (or bodyweight exercises), and running were associated with reduced mortality risk, while some activities showed no clear association. The important thing here is not to turn it into a "best activity guessing game."


This point is also appreciated on social media, with reactions like "It's good that they don't push 'the strongest single activity'" and "In the end, it's about doing multiple things you like, which is realistic." Instead of jumping on the trendy "optimal solution," increasing the number of "multiple options you can continue" raises your chances of success.


But note: The study shows "association," not "guarantee"

This study is observational and primarily based on self-reported data, which has its limitations. Expert comments also point out that people who can engage in diverse exercises may be privileged in terms of time, environment, and resources, and factors other than exercise itself may influence the outcomes. On social media, there are cautious opinions like "Could it be that the variety of exercises decreases as a precursor to illness (reverse causality)?" which is a healthy way to read the study.


That's why it's better to interpret it this way.
It's not "doing diverse exercises will definitely make you live longer," but rather "a lifestyle design that allows for diverse movements may have long-term positive effects.".

Three ways to create "mixed exercises" you can start today

There's no need to overthink it. The important thing is the idea of "adding variety."


1) First, gather three categories

  • Aerobic: brisk walking, light jogging, cycling, swimming (if possible, focus on intensity)

  • Strength: bodyweight squats, push-ups, dumbbells, machines

  • Flexibility/Recovery: stretching, yoga, mobility

This alone significantly reduces "bias."


2) Turn the week into a "set menu"
Example:

  • Monday: brisk walking + light stretching

  • Wednesday: strength training (short duration is fine)

  • Friday: cycling or jogging

  • Weekend: favorite sport/gardening/long walk
    Instead of doing it perfectly every time, design it to fill gaps somewhere in the week to make it sustainable.


3) Count everyday movements as "activities"
Stairs, cleaning, gardening, brisk commuting walks—these are all valid "types of movements." On social media, many voices say, "It's helpful that exercise doesn't have to mean going to the gym." The lower the hurdle, the more likely the habit will stick.

Summary: A new slogan for longevity

"The quantity of exercise is important." This remains true.
However, there's now an additional useful way of thinking.
"If you're going to move the same amount, spread it across various activities.".


In the world of exercise, the more stoic individuals tend to gravitate towards "repeating a single menu." But life is a long-distance run. What matters in the end is continuity, avoiding injury, not getting bored, and maintaining all bodily functions evenly.


Add a light strength training session to today's walk. Take a slightly different path on the weekend. —Such small "additions of variety" might gradually strengthen your future body.


Source URL

Related Articles