Feeling sluggish in the winter? "Vitamin D" might be the answer... but the way you're taking it could actually be dangerous. "Magnesium × Vitamin D" is trending on social media.

Feeling sluggish in the winter? "Vitamin D" might be the answer... but the way you're taking it could actually be dangerous. "Magnesium × Vitamin D" is trending on social media.

From the moment I wake up on a winter morning, my body feels heavy. The short daylight hours tend to dampen my mood, leading me to reach for the supplement shelf with thoughts like "Let's start with Vitamin D" and "Recently, magnesium is also recommended." This scenario is quite a "modern-day commonality." In reality, the supplement market is enormous, with countless combinations of vitamins, minerals, herbs, and amino acids available in stores and online. They are easy to buy and easy to continue using, which is why pitfalls are also increasing.


The main point emphasized in the original article is simple. Supplements are not "harmless health goods," but rather have "dosage and usage" because they are effective. Moreover, the tricky part is that the effects are often felt first. If you feel like "I could sleep better after taking it" or "I feel less anxious," you tend to increase the dosage and variety. However, nutrients have a recommended amount (RDA) set by the government and a tolerable upper intake level (UL) where excessive intake increases risks. Supplements can easily surpass these limits.


First principle: Diet is the foundation, supplements are tools for "filling gaps"

The article repeatedly emphasizes the basics: "Ideally, from food." Food contains nutrients not in isolation but along with elements related to absorption and metabolism (fats, dietary fiber, other minerals, etc.). However, supplements are high-concentration and standalone. While they are useful for those lacking nutrients, for those who don't need them, "adding on" can lead to excessive intake.


The important perspective here is that "adding supplements on your own is akin to adding medication on your own." Especially for those with chronic illnesses, during pregnancy, or on medication (e.g., anticoagulants), interactions and effects on test results can occur. The original article encourages "reporting to healthcare providers." Supplements tend to be taken silently, but the quieter they are, the less visible the risks become.


Quality issues: Don't trust the label too much

Furthermore, as a "scary story," (at least in the U.S.), the system for pre-approval of supplements like pharmaceuticals is weak, and there is little guarantee that the ingredients and amounts are as labeled. This is why the idea of relying on third-party certification (ingredient testing and quality assurance) emerges.


In other words, not only the amount but also "whether that amount is really present" becomes a point of discussion. If the content fluctuates while being consumed for health purposes, it defeats the purpose.


By major supplements: Common misconceptions and "upper limits"

Vitamin D: The winter star, yet excess is dangerous

While vitamin D deficiency is often highlighted, excessive intake can lead to toxicity issues, as the article clearly warns. As a guideline, the recommended amount for adults (19-70 years) is approximately 600 IU (15µg), with an upper limit of 4,000 IU (100µg).
Even when recommended by a healthcare provider, it is advised to start with a standard dose and "recheck blood levels after a few months" rather than jumping into high doses from the beginning.


※ Vitamin D is fat-soluble and tends to accumulate in the body. The more "boosted supplements" trending on social media, the more dangerous this point becomes.


Magnesium: The form (type) changes the experience, and it affects the stomach

Magnesium is often discussed in contexts like "sleep," "muscles," and "stress," and is a central topic on social media. The article explains that magnesium is sold in various forms such as oxides and citrates, and the effects (and side effects) differ by type.
Especially citrate is also used for laxative purposes, so those who are not suited to it may quickly experience abdominal pain or diarrhea.


Regarding the amount, while issues rarely arise from dietary intake, the upper limit from supplements or medications is set at 350mg/day. Exceeding this can lead to nausea, abdominal pain, diarrhea, etc. Additionally, those with weakened kidney function cannot excrete it, raising risks, so self-judgment should be avoided.


Calcium: Rather than taking a large dose at once, "dividing" is the basic approach

Calcium is strongly associated with bones but is also a prime example of what can be easily overdone with supplements. The article mentions a general guideline for adults of 1,000-1,200mg/day, and if taken at once, it should be divided into about 500mg, providing practical advice.


The concern is "overconsumption." Excess from supplements is linked to kidney stone risks, and while research is not unanimous, some studies suggest cardiovascular risks, prompting caution. Furthermore, UK public information introduces the possibility of stomach pain or diarrhea if over 1,500mg/day is consumed.
"More is better for bones" is not the case.


Omega-3: Quality differences and bleeding risk

Omega-3 from fish oil is a representative of "seems healthy," but the article points out that low-quality products are more likely to cause side effects like heartburn and nausea, that the content varies by product, and that other ingredients like vitamins A or D may be included, urging label checking.


Additionally, high doses can increase bleeding risks, so a guideline for the upper limit (e.g., a total of 5g/day from supplements) is provided. Those using anticoagulants should particularly seek consultation.


Vitamin C: The "charm" for cold prevention can also burden the kidneys

Vitamin C tends to be taken with the mindset of "better safe than sorry." The article introduces research suggesting it may slightly shorten the duration of colds but is not a definitive preventive measure, and taking more than 2,000mg/day can lead to gastrointestinal symptoms and kidney stone risks, summarizing it realistically.


Avoid "increasing the burden without benefits."


Others: Probiotics/Creatine/Collagen

freitag.de also touches on supplements that tend to increase under the notion of "seeming healthy."

  • Probiotics: There is no official recommendation for healthy individuals, and high-dose supplements may actually hinder gut microbiota diversity, prompting caution.

  • Creatine: The guideline is 4-5g/day. High doses do not necessarily yield additional benefits, and those with kidney concerns are advised to consult.

  • Collagen: While the safety margin seems wide, the research is not yet robust enough, and it should not be a substitute for complete protein sources.

Ultimately, supplements are not "universal," but "tools with specific uses and compatibilities."


Reactions on social media: The gap between the intensity of personal experiences and the calmness of "upper limits"

This theme spreads easily because social media amplifies "personal experiences."


① The strength of "it worked" reports (especially in the context of anxiety and sleep)
On overseas forums, posts about starting vitamin D and magnesium and feeling "less anxious" or "more positive" stand out. When short-term experiences are shared, they strongly encourage others with similar concerns. However, experiences are influenced by multiple factors like sleep, exercise, seasons, and placebo, making dosage escalation likely.


② The "set drinking" trend (context from TikTok)
The question "Should magnesium and vitamin D be taken together?" itself is trending. Overseas media point out that "high-dose recipes" are spreading on TikTok, but from the perspective of recommended and upper limits, it can lead to excess. The set itself is not necessarily denied, but "for those who need it, in appropriate amounts" is the premise.


③ Posts asserting "magnesium activates vitamin D"
On platforms like Instagram, posts declaring "If you take D, Mg is essential" are also seen. While such assertions are easy to understand, they tend to overlook individual deficiencies, diet, kidney function, and medication. Clarity comes with risk.


④ The backlash of "supplement distrust"
There is also a reaction in the opposite direction. Comments like "In the end, it's about diet, sunlight, and exercise," "Supplements are business," and "If the label can't be trusted, it's scary" are heard. The more this article carefully discusses "quality," "regulation," and "upper limits," the more the distance from supplements as a whole widens. This is also a healthy skepticism.


Conclusions on social media tend to be polarized. Therefore, realistically, **"while referring to personal experiences, make judgments based on test values and upper limits"** is the middle ground.


"Supplement Safety Check" 7 Tips You Can Use Today

  1. Articulate the purpose: Fatigue? Sleep? Deficiency shown in blood tests? If the purpose is vague, it will keep increasing.

  2. Check the recommended amount (RDA) and upper limit (UL): First, do not exceed the "upper limit."

  3. Suspect overlap of multi and single: Are you adding more even though it's in the multi?

  4. Check the form (type): Especially for magnesium, the impact on the stomach changes by type.

  5. Consult first if on medication, have chronic illness, or are pregnant: Interactions and contraindications are possible.

  6. Verify the quality: If possible, choose products with third-party certification or testing systems.

  7. If symptoms appear, "stop" rather than "add": Gastrointestinal symptoms, palpitations, fatigue, etc., can be signs.


Sources

Related Articles