Is the Future of Luxury Brands in Crisis? The Shocking 99% Profit Drop of Porsche: Luxury Shifts from “Things” to Experiences

1) "Strong" Porsche Faces Headwinds

In the third quarter of 2025, Porsche recorded an operating loss of approximately 966 million euros. This was a sharp downturn from the profit in the same quarter of the previous year, with cumulative operating profit from January to September shrinking to just 40 million euros (over 4 billion euros the previous year), and the operating profit margin dropping to 0.2%. The reduction in profit is a shocking "99%." Reuters

These figures are not just a temporary discrepancy. It was a "composite factor settlement" due to increased import tariffs, a slowdown in the fiercely competitive Chinese market, and significant one-time costs associated with a fundamental review of the EV plan. Reuters

2) What Ate into Profits: EVs, Tariffs, China

Porsche has shifted its EV strategy from "quantity to quality," incurring significant costs in restructuring battery-related and development areas. As a result, 2025 is positioned as the "bottom," with a view to re-expansion in 2026. Additionally, the tariff burden on imported cars to the U.S. reached a "hundreds of millions of euros scale," and sales slowed in China, a lifeline in Asia. These factors simultaneously eroded profits. Financial Times

3) A Silver Lining: "Cash is Alive"

Amidst the deficit settlement, cash generation during the period exceeded market expectations. Reports indicated that the free cash flow of the automotive division for the quarter significantly surpassed analyst forecasts, supporting investor sentiment by showing that "cash generation capability remains." It is important to separate short-term special losses from medium- to long-term capital efficiency. Investing.com

4) Steering Management: Implications of Leadership Change

Furthermore, the company is reorganizing its management structure. Observations and announcements of a CEO change towards 2026 continue, currently in a transition period. Who will lead the crisis response, brand value redefinition, and optimal mix of EVs, hybrids, and ICEs will influence next term's market evaluation. Reuters

5) Tectonic Shifts in the "Luxury Economy"

This is not just about Porsche alone. From the latter half of 2024 to 2025, luxury goods are slowing globally, with companies like LVMH also showing sluggish growth. The backdrop includes high interest rates, a slowdown in asset effects, U.S.-China friction, and uncertainty in exchange rates and tariffs. Consumer interest is increasingly shifting from goods to the "premium of experiences," highlighting the relative advantage of luxury travel and hospitality. modaes.com

6) Reactions on Social Media: Between Calm and Passion

It became a major topic in automotive communities on X, Reddit, and Facebook.

• Investment and Management Advocates: Some view the one-time costs of EV investment, tariffs, and Chinese price competition as a "short-term shock." There is cautious optimism with comments like "Cash is flowing, back by 2026." Investing.com

• Product Enthusiasts: There is anticipation for lineup restructuring and strengthening the product power of BEVs and PHEVs. Some interpret reports of model reorganization as "painful normalization." Carscoops

• Emotional Advocates: There is disappointment in the wavering brand myth. Extreme reactions like "Jesus Christ… no wonder why they pulled out of the WEC" were also observed. Reddit

• EV Skeptics: In the comments section on Facebook, posts condemning the "backlash against the EV route" were prominent, while rebuttals pointing out tariffs and Chinese factors were also exchanged. Facebook

7) What "Observer" Reflected: The Context of Headwinds in Luxury

U.S. media Observer positioned this "99% profit drop" as a difficult situation for luxury brands as a whole, emphasizing macro trends that cannot be overcome by brand power alone—high interest rates, geopolitics, and China's slowdown. Porsche's financial results made the "turning point" of the luxury economy visible to the general reader. Observer

8) Future Scenarios: Three Divergences

1. Continuation of Tariffs: The cost of imports to the U.S. remains a burden, limiting the ability to pass on prices and suppressing profit margins.

2. Prolonged Price Competition in China: Optimizing dealer inventory and restructuring pricing are urgent tasks. Can the "meaning of premium" be overwritten with software?

3. EVs as "Chosen Luxury": From uniform electrification to halo PHEV/BEV plus profit pillar ICE/HEV. The key is a high-price, low-volume design philosophy. (FT and Reuters summarize the main causes of this term as the review of EV plans and one-time costs, U.S. tariffs, and China's slowdown. Resetting these is a condition for recovery in 2026.) 
   Financial Times
   
   

9) Practical Checklist (Editorial Perspective)

• Duration and Additional Developments of U.S. Tariffs: Changes in price pass-through rates and mix. Reuters

• Sales and Discount Trends in China: Signs of bottoming out if discount reduction and inventory turnover improvement are observed. Financial Times

• Product Portfolio: Improvements in 911/Cayenne, halo effect of BEV/PHEV, and "speed of monetization." (Continue to watch reports of model reorganization.) Carscoops

• Cash Generation Capability: If free CF stabilizes with the rebound of one-time costs, evaluation recovery will be quick. Investing.com
  
  

References and Sources

• Observer "Porsche's 99% Profit Drop Signals Trouble for Luxury Brands" October 2025 (Starting point for the context of this article). Observer

• Porsche Official Newsroom: Operating profit of 40 million euros from January to September, ROS 0.2%, etc. Porsche Newsroom

• Reuters: Operating loss of approximately 966 million euros in the July-September period, factor analysis. Reuters

• Financial Times: Context of one-time costs for EV plan review, U.S. tariffs, China's slowdown, and management change. Financial Times

• Investing.com: Indication that quarterly cash flow exceeded expectations. Investing.com

• The Economist: Slowdown in luxury goods and shift to travel and experiences. economist.com

• Community Trends: Reactions from Reddit r/cars, Facebook posts, and various media. RedditFacebook

Editorial Note

• Voices from social media are summarized to highlight typical points, using only very short direct quotes (refer to the original text at each link). Primary data was verified as much as possible with official disclosures and major media.