Is the Earth Crying Out Behind the AI Boom? CO2 Emissions from U.S. Data Centers Reach National Levels

Is the Earth Crying Out Behind the AI Boom? CO2 Emissions from U.S. Data Centers Reach National Levels

The Cloud Isn't Above the Sky—U.S. Data Centers Emit "A Country's Worth of CO₂"

When you ask AI a question, it responds in seconds. Photos are stored in the cloud, and videos play without interruption. It's hard to imagine that massive servers are running in distant buildings, continuously consuming electricity.

A study that illustrates this invisible burden with concrete numbers has been published.

According to a report by the German news media ntv on November 16, a research team from Harvard University and others estimated that the CO₂ emissions from electricity use by 403 large data centers in the United States amount to approximately 25.7 million tons annually. This scale is comparable to the annual emissions of a country like Denmark or Bolivia.

However, interpreting this as "AI alone emits a country's worth of CO₂" would be a misinterpretation of the study's significance. The results of this study raise questions not only about the pros and cons of AI usage but also about how the electricity that supports the digital society is generated.


403 Facilities Account for About 1.8% of U.S. Electricity Consumption

The study focused on 403 large data centers in the United States, known as "hyperscale," which were operational from May 2024 to April 2025. The research findings were published in the academic journal "Nature Sustainability."

The main figures introduced by ntv are summarized as follows:

ItemContent Indicated in Research/Reports
Target403 Large Data Centers in the U.S.
Survey PeriodMay 2024 to April 2025
CO₂ Emissions from Electricity UseApproximately 25.7 million tons annually
Proportion of U.S. Electricity ConsumptionAbout 1.8%
Proportion of Electricity from Fossil FuelsAbout 54%

The emissions referred to here are primarily estimates of the CO₂ produced when generating the electricity used by the facilities. It does not mean that this amount of CO₂ is directly emitted from the data center buildings.

Furthermore, the study's scope includes general cloud processing. The university's announcement clearly states that, based on the available data, it was not possible to distinguish between power usage for general operations and AI-specific operations.

Therefore, the 25.7 million tons cannot be simply labeled as "emissions from generative AI." It is also not a figure that covers all data centers in the U.S.


Why "Detective Work" is Necessary to Investigate Power Consumption

It's not easy for users to verify how much electricity is being used by which facilities behind the services they use daily.

In this study, facilities were identified using satellite images, and power consumption was estimated based on operating conditions. Emissions were then allocated using data from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, based on the regional power generation mix.

In other words, the total was not calculated by directly reading the power meters of all facilities.

ntv reports that due to the lack of information disclosure, much of the analysis resembled "detective work." This indicates not only the uncertainty in estimates but also the issue that society lacks sufficient information about facilities that generate huge power demands.

To evaluate the energy-saving goals and environmental policies set by companies, it is essential to be able to verify the power consumption of each facility and how that power is generated.


What Determines Emissions is "How Much is Used" and "How It's Made"

A point of interest in this study is that about 54% of the electricity was derived mainly from fossil fuels such as natural gas and coal.

Even if servers with the same performance run for the same amount of time, the CO₂ emissions will vary depending on the power generation mix of the region supplying the electricity. Efforts to reduce power consumption and to decarbonize the power itself need to be pursued simultaneously.

Here, it is important to distinguish between the contractual power procurement by companies and the actual regional power supply.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) explains that when analyzing the power mix of data centers, they look at the electricity physically supplied through on-site generation or connected power grids, rather than the composition of power contracted by companies.

Increasing the procurement of renewable energy is meaningful. In addition, it is necessary to confirm which power sources are supporting the operation of facilities at specific locations and times.

The question of "whether renewable energy is being purchased" alone cannot capture the reality of power supply.


Criticism of the Environment and Questions on "How to Compare" on Social Media

This study and related reports were shared on the overseas forum Reddit. Posts and comments that could be confirmed included both strong criticism of the environmental impact and opinions questioning how the numbers should be interpreted.

 

In communities dealing with climate issues, posts highlighting the contradiction that the demand for fossil fuels is increasing to power AI, which is expected to help solve climate issues, attracted attention. This perspective prioritizes the immediate power demand and emissions over the potential future benefits of technology.

On the other hand, in related threads in tech communities, there were comments suggesting that even if the total CO₂ emissions from data centers are large, the power mix compared to other electricity uses should also be considered.

This reflects an opinion that questions what criteria are being used for comparison before concluding that "big numbers are bad." However, this comment itself does not prove the high environmental performance of all data centers.

These are limited online reactions and do not represent the overall public opinion. Nonetheless, it can be seen that the discussion is expanding from surprise at the emissions to how to evaluate the quality of power sources and the benefits of technology.


Don't Conclude with Just "Like Denmark"

Comparisons with countries provide a clue to grasp the magnitude of large numbers. However, a country's emissions vary depending on population, industrial structure, target year, and scope of aggregation.

The expression "a country's worth" is a comparison to convey scale and does not determine the necessity or value of the industry.

Similarly, one cannot conclude that the problem is small by looking only at the figure of about 1.8% of U.S. electricity consumption. Even if it fits within a certain percentage nationwide, the impact on power supply can be significant in regions where facilities are concentrated. The IEA also points out the need to consider the global proportion of data centers and their concentrated regional impact separately.

Furthermore, the survey period is until April 2025. It is not a figure that measures the reality as of November 2026.

ntv reports that while the average power scale of the facilities targeted in the study was about 40 megawatts, there are plans like Meta's "Hyperion" that aim for a scale of 5 gigawatts. Although planned capacity and actual power consumption are different, this is an important distinction when considering the future size of facilities.

The figures from this study should be read as capturing a moment in an industry that is rapidly expanding.


Japan Also Needs to Consider "Electricity After Attraction"

This issue is not limited to the United States.

According to the IEA's 2026 update outlook, global data center electricity consumption is expected to nearly double from about 485 terawatt-hours in 2025 to about 950 terawatt-hours by 2030. Of course, this is a future prediction and may change due to technological advances, demand, and supply constraints.

Regarding Japan, the IEA also identifies challenges such as strengthening the power grid, inter-regional connections, and improving connection procedures, in anticipation of increased electricity demand due to the expansion of data centers.

There are three points that Japan should consider from the U.S. study.

First, consider facilities and power sources together. It will be important to secure stable low-carbon electricity, not just land and communication line conditions.

Second, clarify the impact on regions and the burden of costs. When reinforcement of transmission facilities is needed, who will bear which costs? An explanation that satisfies both the region attracting the facilities and the region supplying the electricity is required.

Third, increase verifiable information. Without showing electricity usage, emissions, and calculation methods, it is difficult to judge how effective environmental measures have been.

These are not conclusions directly indicated by the current study regarding Japan, but challenges when considering the results in the context of Japan's capital investment.


Make the Conditions Supporting AI's Convenience Visible

This study does not judge whether the benefits of AI and cloud services outweigh their environmental impact for society as a whole.

What it aimed to reveal is part of the information necessary for that judgment. How much electricity is used, what kind of power generation supports it, and how much CO₂ accompanies it. Without seeing those numbers, it is difficult to confirm the results of improvements.

Digital services that move smoothly on the screen are also connected to real power plants and transmission lines.

Along with AI performance and usage fees, the conditions of the electricity that powers it should also be considered. The estimated 25.7 million tons highlight this necessity.


Sources

  1. ntv: CO₂ emissions from 403 facilities, comparison with countries, fossil fuel ratio, large facility plans, etc.
    https://www.n-tv.de/wirtschaft/CO2-Emissionen-von-US-Rechenzentren-so-hoch-wie-die-ganzer-Laender-id31540894.html

  2. Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health: Official announcement explaining research methods, target period, power consumption estimates, and limitations such as the inability to distinguish AI usage.
    https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/hyperscale-data-centers-energy-consumption-carbon-emissions-newly-estimated-by-researchers/hsph.harvard.edu

  3. Nature Sustainability: Publication site of the current research paper.
    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-026-01985-7

  4. IEA "Energy supply for AI": Analysis distinguishing between contracted procurement composition and the composition of physically supplied electricity.
    https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-and-ai/energy-supply-for-aiIEA

  5. IEA "Key Questions on Energy and AI": Updated outlook on data center power demand from 2025 to 2030.
    https://www.iea.org/reports/key-questions-on-energy-and-aiIEA

  6. IEA "Energy and AI": Explanation of the impact of data center power demand concentration in regions.
    https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-and-ai/executive-summaryIEA

  7. IEA "Japan 2026 Energy Policy Review": Report organizing issues such as increased power demand in Japan, power grid development, and system connections.
    https://www.iea.org/files/ab97a4d0-393c-453e-9366-9c766f37d31b/Japan2026.pdfiea.org

  8. Reddit・r/climate: Related posts criticizing the contradiction between expectations for AI in climate measures and the increase in fossil fuel demand. The SNS section summarizes the gist.
    https://www.reddit.com/r/climate/comments/1xxqvq1/reddit.com

  9. Reddit・r/technology: Related threads containing comments suggesting that in addition to total emissions, comparisons with other electricity uses and power mix should be considered. The SNS section summarizes the gist.
    https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1xxwexf/