Is Banning Cell Phones the Key to Academic Improvement? Does Prohibiting Smartphones in Schools Affect Grades? Insights from Comparing "Score Improvements" in 4,600 U.S. Schools

Is Banning Cell Phones the Key to Academic Improvement? Does Prohibiting Smartphones in Schools Affect Grades? Insights from Comparing "Score Improvements" in 4,600 U.S. Schools

"1 to 2 weeks per year" - What does this number measure?

Even if students attend school for the same number of days, there can be differences in how much they learn from autumn to spring. What if part of that difference is related to where they store their smartphones during school?

The New York Times reported on November 17 about a nationwide study conducted by the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard University and others. The team analyzed data from about 4,600 schools and approximately 3.3 million students across 49 states and Washington, D.C., from the 2021-22 to 2025-26 school years. The subjects were students in grades equivalent to Japan's third grade of elementary school to first grade of high school.

The researchers focused not on schools with posters saying "No Smartphones," but on schools where students placed their smartphones in lockable pouches after arriving at school, making them inaccessible during school hours. They tracked individual growth in math and reading using the "MAP Growth" tests taken in autumn and spring, comparing changes before and after implementation with similar schools that did not adopt the system.

In schools that introduced the pouches, the average growth over a year was about 0.01 standard deviations larger in both subjects. When expressed as a measure of how much academic performance typically improves in regular classes, this difference equates to about 1 to 2 weeks. This does not mean actual class time increased; rather, it reflects the size of the learning gap that emerged over the same period from autumn to spring.


Comparing the small difference to the prolonged decline in academic performance

The significance of this number becomes clearer when compared to changes experienced by American children even before the COVID-19 pandemic. In the U.S., math and reading scores had been gradually declining since around 2013. Although the annual decline might seem small, over several years, the gap compared to previous cohorts widens.

According to the research team's estimates, the annual gain observed after introducing the pouches corresponds to about half of the average annual decline in academic performance experienced by students before the pandemic. Interpreting this as "half of the lost academic performance was regained by banning smartphones" would be an overestimation of the effect.

Improvements were observed from the first year of implementation and appeared to continue three years later. No statistical differences in the magnitude of the effect were found based on pre-implementation performance or school level. In reading, there was also a possibility that the proportion of students who significantly dropped in performance over a year decreased. Behind the result of a slight increase in average scores, there might be a change where fewer students struggled significantly.

However, this was not an experiment where schools were randomly divided into implementation and non-implementation groups. Moreover, even if the period of smartphone proliferation coincided with the period of academic decline, it cannot be solely determined how much of the past decline was due to smartphones. What was directly compared this time was how the growth in student performance changed before and after implementing the system of storing smartphones at school for a day.


What teachers discussed on social media was more about lunchtime than tests

One change not reflected in the numbers is the sound during lunchtime. Before the research presentation, a poster on Reddit, a forum for U.S. teachers, wrote about being surprised by the difference after their district introduced lockable pouches for grades 6-12. In the same thread, another poster reported that in middle school, the students' voices during lunch were almost too loud to handle. While discussions revolve around whether students can concentrate quietly in the classroom, another scene emerges where break times become lively.

 

Another teacher asked a more practical question. If a school where students can leave campus during lunch implements pouches, do they unlock them at the start of lunch and lock them again when they return? A rule that seems to only require locking in the morning and unlocking at the end of the day becomes a question of who does what at the entrance during lunch when applied to the school's daily routine.

These are not impressions from reading the current research but voices from the field exchanged during the implementation or consideration stages. It is not possible to directly link the increase in reading scores with the livelier lunchtimes using the current data. Nevertheless, there is a clear reason to ask students and teachers about what aspects of school life change.


In Japan, can "wanting to let them carry it to and from school" and "wanting to store it during class" coexist?

In Japanese households, smartphones might be more necessary on the way home rather than during class. When trains stop, club activities end late, or the pick-up location needs to be changed. The reasons parents want their children to carry devices and the reasons teachers don't want screens viewed during class can coexist if separated by time.

The Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology's 2020 notification also makes this distinction. While the general rule is to prohibit bringing mobile phones to elementary and junior high schools, exceptions for individual circumstances are anticipated. In junior high schools, if the school and students/parents agree on management methods and necessary environments are established, bringing phones may be permitted at the discretion of the school or board of education. Options include prohibiting use within the school or temporarily storing phones after arrival and returning them at dismissal.

Therefore, when Japanese schools read this research, the starting point will be the existing school rules and realities. The meaning of adding lockable pouches differs between schools where everyone deposits their devices after arriving and schools where teachers ask students to store them during each class. The "1 to 2 weeks per year" observed in the U.S. cannot be directly expected in Japan.

What schools may want to verify instead is how often explanations are interrupted by attention to smartphones during class, how lunchtime habits change, and where urgent messages can be received. While the effect may appear on report cards a year later, clues about whether the rules are working well can be found in tomorrow's classrooms and lunch breaks.


Source