What are the surprising habits of people who can forgive themselves? New research reveals the art of mental switching

What are the surprising habits of people who can forgive themselves? New research reveals the art of mental switching

On the train ride home, I recall the daytime meeting. I interrupted a junior colleague during their explanation, saying, "I've heard that before." I wish I had listened to the rest of it. At the very least, I could have said it more gently. As I gaze out the train window, the same meeting has replayed in my mind three times already.

The German women's magazine 'BRIGITTE' covered the psychology behind such "solo reflection sessions." The trigger was a friend hesitating to order the pizza they wanted at a restaurant, worried about pronouncing its name correctly. A mispronunciation that someone at the next table would forget in seconds could become an event the person replays multiple times after returning home.

So, when someone has actually hurt another or failed in an important situation, how do those who have forgiven themselves and those who still blame themselves narrate their experiences?


Feeling as if something from years ago happened just now

Lydia Woodyatt and her colleagues at Flinders University in Australia analyzed the accounts of 80 people regarding experiences where they felt they had failed or done something wrong. Forty-one people said they couldn't forgive themselves, while 39 said they could. This qualitative study, published in 2025, interpreted the characteristics that emerged in their narratives. From this breakdown, it's not accurate to say that half of the world cannot forgive themselves.

One of the differences was the distance from the event. In the accounts of those who couldn't forgive themselves, there was a sense that failures from years ago were pressing upon them as if happening now. In the meeting example, the harshness of one's voice and the awkwardness of the moment when the other person stopped speaking would return each time. No matter how many alternate endings one considers with "If only I had stayed silent," the person in memory always stops speaking at the same point.

On the other hand, in the narratives of those who could forgive themselves, there was mention of how the experience influenced their subsequent choices. Even if they remember the same scene, when they say, "Since then, I've learned to wait until people finish speaking," the story continues beyond that day's meeting room.


There's a distance between "I interrupted the conversation" and "I can't listen to people"

Another difference that emerged in the study was what conclusions people draw about themselves from a single action.

"I interrupted that person's conversation." Here, there is the other person, the situation, and what one did. However, when it becomes "I am a person who can't listen to others," that one statement of the day becomes an evaluation that applies to one's past and future self. The latter sounds like a more severe reflection. Yet, it's easier to ask what the junior colleague was trying to convey in the former case.

This also overlaps with the difference in what one believes they have the power to change. You can't take back words once spoken. You can't choose how the other person receives them. Still, there's room to start the next meeting with, "I'd like to hear the rest of what you were saying yesterday."

Of course, when people blame themselves, it doesn't necessarily mean they were truly at fault. The study also included narratives of people who felt guilty about experiences where they were the victims. There's a significant gap between being able to say "I would do this now" and being able to say "I should have been able to do that back then."


The time after apologizing, as discussed on social media

In November 2026, a query was posted on the English-speaking bulletin board-style social media site "Reddit." The poster explained that in their attempt to cope with their own struggles, they unintentionally hurt someone. They reflected on why they did it, changed their behavior, and apologized to the other person. Yet, feelings of embarrassment, guilt, and regret remained. They asked how they could forgive themselves.

 

One response suggested that the feeling of having forgiven oneself might come gradually. When reflecting on one's past self, it's okay to also focus on what kind of person one is trying to become now. Another person contributed words to the effect that knowing things now that were not understood then allows for different actions in the future.

This exchange about the same dilemma occurred before the 'BRIGITTE' article was published. The poster was not struggling with what to apologize for. Even after doing what they felt was necessary, their feelings didn't catch up with the notion that "this was the right thing to do." The respondents were trying to address that time lag.


Listening to the rest at tomorrow's meeting

The fourth theme highlighted in the original paper was coping with painful feelings. Trying to calm the distress versus facing what happened and considering its meaning for oneself. The researchers discerned this difference in the participants' narratives. It wasn't a study confirming that trying a specific way of thinking would erase regret.

Let's return to the train ride home. If that one remark still bothers you, try narrowing the question "Why am I always like this?" to "What was that person trying to say?" There are things you can't figure out no matter how many times you think about them in your head. That's why it gives you a reason to ask the person for the rest tomorrow.

That night, the awkwardness might remain. However, if you can wait for the junior colleague to finish speaking at the next day's meeting, you'll have one more scene to recall when reflecting on yesterday.


Sources