Waist circumference as a warning sign for diabetes risk: Same height, same weight. Why does the diabetes risk still differ?

Waist circumference as a warning sign for diabetes risk: Same height, same weight. Why does the diabetes risk still differ?

The weight is the same as last year. Yet the pants are tight—The relationship between waist circumference and diabetes revealed in a study of 130,000 women

Last year's pants are a bit tight around the waist. But when you step on the scale, the numbers are almost unchanged. In such cases, where should you look in your health check results?

The clue lies in the "waist circumference" listed next to weight and BMI. A study of 133,620 women in the United States found that even if BMI falls within the same range, groups with larger waist circumferences tend to develop type 2 diabetes more easily. What the scale overlooks is not how many more kilos there are, but where that weight is distributed on the body.


Differences that don't show up in BMI, even with the same height and weight

For example, if there are two people who are 160 cm tall and weigh 60 kg, both will have a BMI of about 23.4. One can still comfortably wear pants from a few years ago, while the other's waist has become tight, yet the calculation result is the same. The BMI formula only includes height and weight, not the amount of muscle or where fat is distributed.

On the other hand, waist circumference is a clue to estimating how much fat is around the abdomen. Particularly related to metabolism is visceral fat, which accumulates around abdominal organs. However, a measuring tape can only measure up to the body's external circumference. It doesn't reveal how many centimeters are subcutaneous fat and how many are visceral fat. Therefore, the research team investigated how well combining BMI with waist circumference could distinguish future risk of onset.


What was learned from tracking 130,000 people, and what can't be read from individual numbers

The study, published in the journal of the American Endocrine Society on October 31, 2026, targeted women who participated in the U.S. "Women's Health Initiative" and did not have type 2 diabetes at the start of the survey. The research team created an analysis framework with data from about 70% of the participants and verified it with the remaining 30%. When further verified with two other groups, the relationship between waist circumference and onset risk showed the same direction.

What is important when reading the results is who was compared to whom. The study found that when women in the same BMI category were divided by waist circumference, the group with larger waist circumferences generally had a higher tendency to develop type 2 diabetes during the follow-up. Among the participants, this difference was more pronounced in relatively younger age groups.

So, if your waist circumference increased by 3 cm from last year, how much does your risk of onset increase? This study cannot apply a multiplier to this question. This is because "comparison of people with different waist circumferences" and "comparison before and after a single person's waist circumference changes" are different questions. The researchers themselves explain that even when combining BMI and waist circumference, there are limitations to predicting individual onset.


A simple question raised on social media: "Where do you measure the waist?"

When trying to record waist circumference, the first stumbling block is the position of the measuring tape. On the English-speaking forum Reddit, specific experiences on this point were exchanged even before this FOCUS article was published.

 

In a November post, someone measured both the narrowest part and the height of the navel to ensure consistent comparisons. For this person, there was a difference of about 3 inches, or about 7.6 cm, between the two positions. In another thread, someone wanting to record changes other than weight was confused when different numbers appeared even when measured three times at the same time. The reply asked whether the measuring tape was rising or falling on the back side.

Neither is a direct comment on the paper, but they convey important points when reading health check forms. The "waist" when choosing clothes and the "waist circumference" in health checks may sometimes be measured in different places. If you're concerned about a few centimeters difference from the last time, the first thing to check is whether the measuring tape was placed in the same spot as before.


In Japanese health check forms, look at the waist circumference and blood sugar sections together

If measuring at home to match Japanese health checks, stand naturally and wrap the measuring tape horizontally at the height of the navel. Read the scale while exhaling normally without sucking in your stomach. If you turn sideways in a mirror, it's easier to check if the measuring tape is not misaligned on the back side.

The "85 cm or more for men, 90 cm or more for women" seen in Japan's specific health checks is one criterion used to evaluate risks from visceral fat accumulation and to consider who should receive health guidance. It's not a boundary line where exceeding by 1 cm means developing diabetes and being 1 cm below means being safe.

If you have last year's and this year's health check forms on hand, you may want to line up the sections for weight, waist circumference, and fasting blood sugar or HbA1c. Waist circumference provides clues about changes in body shape, while blood tests offer insights into blood sugar status. If waist circumference continues to increase despite stable weight, this progression can be reported during health checks or consultations. Conversely, even if waist circumference is below the guideline, if there are instructions for re-examination or consultation in the blood sugar section, follow those instructions for confirmation.

Just because last year's pants are tight doesn't mean you have diabetes. However, there's no need to end the conversation by just looking at the scale. Take out last year's health check form. The numbers from the measuring tape are useful in such situations.


Source