Freedom of the Press in Crisis in Hong Kong? "No Reason" Notice: Visa Renewal Rejection and the Transformation of Hong Kong's Media Landscape

1｜What Happened

Rebecca Choong-Wilkins, a Bloomberg journalist based in Hong Kong, had her work visa renewal denied without explanation. While the Immigration Department refrained from commenting on individual cases, it stated that it processes applications "in accordance with the law and policies." Bloomberg, her employer, is addressing the situation. The facts were confirmed by the FCC (Foreign Correspondents' Club, Hong Kong) in a statement, highlighting the lack of transparency as a concern.Reutersfcchk.org

2｜Why It Matters——The "Seismic Shift" in Numbers

In the 2025 RSF World Press Freedom Index, Hong Kong fell to 140th place, entering the "very serious" red zone for the first time. This sharp decline from 18th place in 2002 is unprecedented. The drop in the index is statistically supported by the accumulation of individual cases, with the recent visa denial being part of this trend.rsf.org

3｜Historical Context——The Déjà Vu of Journalist Visas

In the past, Hong Kong authorities have also tightened decisions regarding visas for international media personnel. For instance, in 2021, a journalist from The Economist was denied a visa renewal, and in 2024, Bloomberg journalist Haze Fan's work visa application was reportedly rejected without public announcement. Although the circumstances differ, the common issue is the lack of transparency.BloombergThe Straits Times

4｜The "Concurrent" Judicial and Regulatory Environment

The expansion of the National Security Law's application has manifested as both direct and indirect pressure on media organizations. A symbolic case is the prolonged trial of Apple Daily founder Jimmy Lai, which continues to draw international attention concerning judicial independence and press freedom. Allegations of pressure through tax audits and economic measures have also surfaced, increasing the costs and risks for newsrooms.AP NewsThe Guardian

5｜Reactions Spread on Social Media

The news quickly spread on X (formerly Twitter) and Facebook. Reuters journalist James Pomfret shared the situation with a link. Bloomberg colleague Ian Marlow expressed his disappointment, stating, "It's really unfortunate despite the great work." The FCC's official post was widely shared among media professionals, with many comments calling for transparency and clearer standards.X (formerly Twitter)Facebook

6｜Three Issues Raised by the "Unexplained Denial"

① Transparency: With little explanation of the review criteria and decisions, journalists in similar positions find it difficult to plan for the future. The FCC is calling for a "swift and transparent review."fcchk.org
② Contradiction with Talent Attraction: While aiming to attract international talent, restricting access to journalists who ensure information reliability could impact the city's brand and risk premium.
③ Corporate Operations: Multinational media may have to reconsider the rotation of journalists based in Hong Kong, legal and security costs, and the reallocation of remote reporting setups (such as in Singapore, Taipei, Tokyo, etc.).

7｜The "Invisible Costs" for Those Involved

According to AFP, Choong-Wilkins was forced to leave Hong Kong after six years, adding personal burdens. The disruption of an individual's life foundation, coupled with a lack of institutional accountability, increases the risk of international journalism talent avoiding Hong Kong.The New Indian Express

8｜Implications for Investors and Readers

Markets are sensitive to the speed and diversity of information flow. If journalist access becomes unstable, analyzing policies, regulations, and corporate trends becomes more challenging. Consequently, news flow may become biased towards "official windows" such as corporate disclosures, court documents, and international conferences, risking a loss of on-the-ground insights and critical scrutiny.

9｜Timeline (Key Points)

• August 22, 2025: FCC confirms and issues a statement on the visa renewal denial.fcchk.org

• August 23: Reuters reports Bloomberg's "response to resolve the issue."Reuters

• From the same day: HKFP provides detailed coverage, spreading on social media.Hong Kong Free Press HKFPFacebook

10｜Indicators to Measure the Future

• The extent to which the administration will make the reasons for visa decisions and the appeal process transparent.

• Whether international media will reallocate resources (strengthening bases in Singapore, Seoul, Taipei, Tokyo, etc.).

• The 2026 RSF Index, field hearings by HKJA, and the frequency of new frictions due to tax and law enforcement.The Guardian

Powered by Froala Editor