Concerns About the "Three-Tiered Healthcare" Expanding in Germany: Can You Get Seen Faster If You Pay?

Concerns About the "Three-Tiered Healthcare" Expanding in Germany: Can You Get Seen Faster If You Pay?

I've been experiencing ongoing health issues. I want to consult a specialist. However, when trying to make an appointment using insurance, it's hard to secure a booking. On the other hand, if I pay the medical fees out of pocket, I might be able to see a doctor sooner.

Faced with such a choice, what would we feel?

Currently in Germany, there's a heated debate over specialist appointments and out-of-pocket expenses. The controversy began with a statement by Andreas Gassen, the chairman of the Federal Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians (KBV), which represents doctors responsible for public health insurance services.

If medical fees are reduced, more public insurance subscribers might opt for out-of-pocket consultations to avoid long waiting times for appointments. This outlook has sparked backlash from insurers, politicians, and patient advocacy groups.

The issue isn't just about providing options for those willing to pay extra fees. It's about the trust in the public system that those paying insurance premiums can access medical care when needed.


It's not just about "paying a reservation fee"

Let's clarify first. Germany hasn't decided on a nationwide "paid specialist appointment" system.

Gassen's statement was a prediction that more medical institutions would offer out-of-pocket consultation slots due to reduced medical fees.

Moreover, the explained system isn't just about adding a small reservation fee to regular insurance consultations. It involves receiving treatment outside of public insurance as a private patient, with the patient bearing the costs.

In Japanese, "faster appointments for an extra fee" might easily be imagined as a fee to expedite the order of consultations. However, in this debate, the key point is shifting the medical consultation itself outside of insurance coverage.

Gassen argues that clinics don't have an infinite obligation to provide care, and it's unrealistic to expect the same level of service when fees are being cut. He highlighted fields particularly affected, such as ENT, orthopedics, cardiology, radiology, and rheumatology.


The situation doctors describe: "Seeing more patients doesn't necessarily solve the problem"

From a patient's perspective, the reason for not getting an appointment might simply seem like "there aren't enough doctors." However, it's not just a lack of consultation time; the payment system for consultations is also involved.

According to Gassen, even if medical institutions that have exhausted their public insurance budgets accept additional patients, they can't sufficiently cover the necessary costs. As a result, it's possible that desired clinic appointments can't be secured until the next quarter.

Medical institutions have burdens such as personnel costs, equipment costs, and rent. The argument that increasing consultation slots requires not just the goodwill of doctors but also the necessary staff and income is a point worth considering.

However, the need for "funds to maintain operations" and the appropriateness of "asking patients who want to be seen quickly to pay out of pocket" should be considered separately.

Even those who understand the former might strongly oppose the latter. This conflict arises precisely at that intersection.


Why is it criticized as "three-tiered healthcare"?

In Germany, there has been concern about the disparity in ease of securing specialist appointments between patients with public health insurance and those with private health insurance.

What happens when public insurance subscribers who can choose out-of-pocket consultations are added to the mix?

Those receiving care through private insurance. Those in public insurance who can choose faster consultations by paying out of pocket. And those who have no choice but to wait within the public insurance framework. The differences in payment ability will also spread among public insurance subscribers.

Janosh Dahmen, the health policy spokesperson for the Green Party, expressed concerns about this "three-tiered" system. The criticism is that the lack of appointment slots should not lead to a business of extracting additional payments from patients.

For patients, the time until a consultation is not merely a matter of convenience. It's time spent working while in pain, waiting anxiously for a diagnosis, and being unable to plan one's life.

Of course, long waiting times don't immediately lead to worsening conditions. However, a system where only those who can pay can shorten that time raises questions about the fairness of healthcare.


Are fees being reduced or increased?

What complicates the debate is how the numbers regarding medical expenses are interpreted.

According to a tagesschau analysis, the KBV estimates a reduction in revenue of about 1.64 billion euros annually due to the abolition of TSVG fees related to speeding up appointments, and a reduction of about 2.7 billion euros in the outpatient sector the following year. Gassen mentioned a reduction of about 3 billion euros.

On the other hand, the same article reports that a 2.2% increase in medical fees for 2027 has been agreed upon, which insurers say will result in an increase of about 1.1 billion euros.

These aren't simply a matter of one being wrong. Even if part of the fees are increased, the abolition of other surcharges means the impact varies by specialty and medical institution.

Moreover, simply subtracting amounts shown in different ranges and standards doesn't reveal the reality.

What's needed is not just the big picture of "whether overall physician fees will increase or decrease," but understanding which specialties, in which regions, and for which patients the support system will weaken.


Did increasing funds not resolve the waiting times?

There are reasons for insurers to push back against the demands of doctors.

In Germany, additional fees were introduced based on the 2019 Appointment Service and Supply Act (TSVG) to expedite appointments. However, according to the Federal Audit Office's findings introduced in the original article, despite significant additional spending, the reduction in waiting times was not achieved.

The question here is not just the amount of the budget, but what the money is being spent on.

Did the additional fees truly expedite necessary patient consultations? What were the regional and specialty differences? Was the situation of patients who couldn't secure appointments fully understood?

It's not enough to simply continue a system that hasn't proven effective. Conversely, just cutting fees because of limited effectiveness doesn't necessarily make consultations more accessible.

What is needed is a payment method that ties both maintaining medical institutions and reducing patient wait times.


Visible on social media: dissatisfaction over "what are insurance premiums for?"

In the German-speaking public threads on Reddit regarding this news, there's dissatisfaction about having to pay medical fees out of pocket while also bearing insurance premiums.

 

One post sarcastically asked if the out-of-pocket expenses could be deducted from the monthly insurance premiums. Another questioned whether they would have to bear the costs of consultations themselves as insurance premiums continue to rise.

These are not posts explaining the institutional handling. They express dissatisfaction with the need for additional payments to secure essential consultations despite being insured.

Another thread pointed out that the previously two-tiered healthcare system is moving towards a three-tiered one. There is concern about the division among public insurance subscribers based on whether they can access out-of-pocket services.

What these posts reveal is not just anger over price increases. It's the gap between the expectation that "if you pay insurance premiums, you should have access to necessary medical care" and the reality of not being able to secure appointments.

However, what is introduced here is a summary of some public posts and does not represent the opinion distribution of the entire German society. The burden amounts and individual circumstances mentioned by the posters should be distinguished from independently verified statistics.


The government's aim is a system that first connects patients to family doctors

According to the original article, the coalition government aims to reform the system centered on primary care to improve access to specialists.

The basic idea is to first see a family doctor and be referred to a specialist if necessary. Instead of patients continuing to search for appointments individually, the medical side is expected to coordinate the consultation destination and timing.

Additionally, it has been reported that an obligation has been introduced for doctors responsible for insurance consultations to report appointment slots to the existing reservation service desk "116117."

However, handling appointment slots centrally doesn't automatically increase consultation capacity. Gassen criticizes that securing a certain number of slots for the service desk means they can't be used for regular patients of that clinic.

This criticism highlights that making appointments "visible" and "increasing the total number of appointments" are different.

Nonetheless, if available slots are appropriately shared and patients are guided according to medical urgency, the use of limited consultation capacity can be improved. In evaluating the reform, it's necessary to look not just at the setup of the service desk but also at how quickly necessary patients could actually be seen.


For Japan too, "having insurance" and "being able to see a doctor" are not the same

In Germany and Japan, insurance systems, patient out-of-pocket expenses, and access mechanisms to specialists differ. It's premature to consider this issue as a direct future scenario for Japan.

However, there are common considerations.

Being insured. Being able to afford medical fees. Being able to secure an appointment when needed. These are separate issues.

Even if the system allows for consultations, if appointments are too far ahead or there are no accessible consultation locations, medical care remains distant for patients.

And those who find it difficult to wait may have no choice but to accept additional expenses. Even if it's an out-of-pocket consultation chosen by the individual, whether that choice is supported by sufficient insurance consultation options needs careful consideration.

The German debate isn't about choosing between protecting the management of medical institutions or reducing patient burdens.

It's about the difficulty of delivering necessary resources to the medical field while creating a system that doesn't leave the prioritization of consultations up to payment ability.

Trust in medical care isn't established just by having an insurance card. It's supported by the experience of being able to see a doctor when in need.


Sources

  1. tagesschau: An article organizing the background of the current debate, the reduction and increase of medical fees, and the reactions of politicians, insurers, and patient groups, published on November 15, 2026.
    https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/gesellschaft/arzttermine-selbst-zahlen-debatte-100.htmlwarum der Vorstoß für Empörung sorgt

  2. tagesschau: Reporting on Gassen's prediction of increased out-of-pocket consultation slots and the impact on budgets and medical specialties.
    https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/gesetzlich-versicherte-behandlung-selbstzahler-100.htmltagesschau.de

  3. Deutschlandfunk: An article reporting on the criticism from insurers and political concerns about "paywalling healthcare."
    https://www.deutschlandfunk.de/kritik-an-selbstzahler-vorstoss-von-gassen-108.htmlKritik an Selbstzahler-Vorstoß von Gassen

  4. Reddit/r/de: A summary of public threads regarding the current news, highlighting posts about the overlap of insurance premiums and out-of-pocket expenses.
    https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/1xvx722/reddit.com

  5. Reddit/r/Nachrichten: Public posts mentioning the three-tiered healthcare system and differences among public insurance subscribers based on payment ability.
    https://www.reddit.com/r/Nachrichten/comments/1xwotzj/