Your Food Choices Can Save the Planet! What Matters More Than Origin is the Impact on Climate

Your Food Choices Can Save the Planet! What Matters More Than Origin is the Impact on Climate

What Happens Before Ingredients Begin Their Journey

Let's make curry tonight. When you pick up a pack of beef at the supermarket, the label shows the place of origin. You can imagine the approximate distance to your kitchen. However, the label doesn't tell you how much feed the cow consumed or how much greenhouse gas it emitted during its lifetime.

A research team from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology investigated the climate impact of both domestic and imported foods consumed in Norway, including the less visible aspects. For imported goods, they also calculated emissions produced in the country of origin. As a result, the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the country's food consumption were estimated to be about 11.6 million tons annually. This figure includes the impact of methane and other gases converted into carbon dioxide equivalents.

Of this, food transportation accounted for 3.8%. Transporting food from afar does consume fuel. However, if a crop is grown in an area where it thrives, the emissions reduced during the production phase can sometimes offset the increase from long-distance transportation. Simply measuring the distance on a map doesn't reveal this difference.


Beef Alone Accounts for About a Quarter of Total Food Emissions

Of the food consumed in Norway, domestic products account for 42% by weight. However, when looking at greenhouse gas emissions, they account for 65%. To understand this discrepancy, it's necessary to see what's in the domestic shopping basket.

In Norway's domestic production, meat and dairy products occupy a large share. Raising cattle requires feed, which also uses land and energy for production. Additionally, cows and sheep emit methane during the digestion of grass and other feed. When comparing the foods studied by emissions per kilogram, beef had the highest emissions. Beef alone accounted for 23.8% of the emissions associated with Norway's food consumption.

Thus, from the statistics showing a high proportion of emissions from domestic products, one cannot conclude that replacing domestic carrots with imported ones will reduce emissions. The gap between 42% and 65% includes differences not only in where they were grown but also in what was grown, such as beef versus carrots.


Changing the Place of Origin vs. Changing the Menu

The research team also estimated the impact of significantly changing the sourcing of ingredients or the content of meals. The figures below show how much Norway's food-related greenhouse gas emissions would increase or decrease compared to a baseline diet.

Conditions for EstimationChange in Total Food Emissions
Covering Almost All Food Needs Domestically4% Increase
Importing All Food1.5% Decrease
Replacing All Red Meat in Meals with Plant-Based Proteins34% Decrease

Even when significantly leaning towards either domestic or imported sourcing, the change was only a few percent. In contrast, the difference was much larger when red meat was replaced with plant-based proteins. The 34% figure is an estimate based on the assumption of changing the entire country's diet, not the reduction rate when a Japanese household changes its dinner once.

Nevertheless, when brought to the shopping scene, the meaning of the research becomes clear. Once you decide to make beef curry and compare the origins of the meat, the options are limited to within the beef category. If you take a step back to the point of deciding the menu, chickpea and tomato curry can also be a candidate. Choices that significantly affect the emissions from your dining table exist even before reaching the meat section.


Reasons for Choosing Local Products Discussed on Social Media

How do people perceive buying local products? Before this research was published, a question was raised in the English-speaking bulletin board-style SNS "Reddit" community "ZeroWaste" about how much importance people place on buying local food.

 

The original poster explained that they consciously eat locally grown food and are fortunate to be in an environment where it is easily accessible. On the other hand, replies included opinions that what you eat has a greater impact on emissions than how far the ingredients have traveled. Some people gave examples of a vegetarian diet using ingredients from afar versus a meal centered around local meat.

This exchange reflects two overlapping questions in daily shopping: Do you want to buy from nearby producers? Do you want to reduce greenhouse gases from your meals? For example, if you choose seasonal vegetables at a local farmers' market and stew them with beans, you can value both in a single menu.


What to See Beyond the Place of Origin Label on Japanese Dining Tables

The 3.8% figure from Norway cannot be directly applied to Japanese food transportation. This is because what and how much is eaten, what is produced domestically, and how and from where it is transported differ. Additionally, researchers point out that the ability to produce food domestically has significance in supporting supply during emergencies. Water and land use, as well as impacts on biodiversity, need to be considered separately from greenhouse gases.

What can be taken back to Japanese dining tables is not an answer of foreign or domestic, but another question that can be used when shopping. How about using more tofu and less beef in the usual meat and tofu dish? For curry, is there a bean recipe that the family would want to eat again? The opportunity to choose the place of origin exists in the market. What and how much to eat can be chosen from that day's menu.


Sources