Is That "Cute Plate" Actually Dangerous? ─ The Story of Vintage Tableware and Heavy Metals

Is That "Cute Plate" Actually Dangerous? ─ The Story of Vintage Tableware and Heavy Metals

1) Why "Old Tableware" is Popular Now

Floral plates, cobalt blue soup tureens, gold-rimmed service dishes. Tableware that had been sleeping in the back of closets is now taking center stage at flea markets, antique fairs, reuse shops, and in social media posts of dining tables. The warmth of patterns not found in new items, the texture imbued with the air of the times, and the story of "using something inherited." That's why you want to use them on your dining table the moment you acquire them.


However, just as much as their "charm," the reality that "old techniques and materials may not meet modern standards" is often overlooked. The risk that became a topic of discussion this time was precisely at this boundary.


2) The Issue Centers on "Glaze" and "Heavy Metals"

According to reports, some ceramics and tableware made from the early 20th century to around 1950 used heavy metals in the glaze to fire at low temperatures. Lead and cadmium were particularly pointed out. They have been historically used to bring out vivid colors, stabilize hues, and improve the finish.


What is worrisome here is not "that they are present" but rather "that they can transfer to food depending on how they are used." Tableware is a "container," but depending on the length of contact time and the nature of the food, trace elements may migrate (leach) to the food side. In other words, tableware is not "just a background" but can also be a stage for chemical reactions on the dining table.


3) The More Acidic, the Easier to Leach—There's a "Compatibility with Dishes"

The keyword that repeatedly appears in warnings is "acidic foods." Tomato sauce, citrus, vinegar, dressings, fruit juices, carbonated drinks, wine, coffee, and tea—everyday menus are surprisingly acidic. Acid can easily extract components from the glaze surface, and the risk changes depending on "what you place" on the same plate.


For example, "fish with squeezed lemon," "tomato stew," "vinegared dishes," "berry desserts." Dishes that are striking in color and taste are more likely to be a concern from the perspective of leaching. It's troublesome when the appeal of the dish and the conditions for safety diverge here.


4) "It's Not Chipped, So It's Okay" is Not True

A common reaction seen on social media is, "Isn't it fine if there are no cracks?" This is understandable as an intuition. When there are chips or cracks, the surface appears rough and seems likely to leach.


However, the warning this time emphasizes that "migration can occur regardless of the presence of chips or cracks." Even if it looks clean, the composition of the glaze, firing conditions, aging, and daily washing and abrasion make it difficult to judge the surface condition by sight alone. In other words, there are limits to "visual checks."


5) What Health Risks Are Being Discussed?

Lead is widely known as a harmful substance that can accumulate in the body, and its health effects on children have been a concern. Long-term exposure is undesirable even for adults. Cadmium is also discussed for its effects on the kidneys and bones and is said to remain in the body due to its long half-life.


Of course, the important thing here is not to make it a story of "using it once is immediately out." The issue is the multiplication of "frequency" and "conditions." Using acidic foods in prolonged contact almost daily. The more these conditions overlap, the more the risk accumulates. Conversely, by changing how you use them, there is "room to reduce the risk."


6) A Realistic Compromise: "Separate Uses" Rather Than Discarding

So, should all vintage tableware be disposed of? The conclusion is that there is no need to go to extremes. The point is to "remove the use as tableware from eating purposes."


For example, use them as decorative plates. Use them as trays for keys or accessories. Use them as vessels for dried flowers. Use them as props for photography. This way, you can retain the "aesthetic" value while reducing contact with the mouth.


If you want to go further, there is a "conditional operation" for those who "absolutely want to use them." A typical example is placing fruit but only "those that are peeled." Even if the food directly touches it, the part that is ultimately eaten is shaped to be less likely to come into contact. This way of thinking is becoming a popular "compromise" on social media.


7) More People Want to "Decide After Testing"

Looking at social media reactions, emotions are largely divided into three categories.


(A) Anxiety/Shock Group
Reactions such as "All our everyday dishes are retro..." and "I've been using them unknowingly for years" are direct because they are connected to daily life. Especially in households with children, the reactions are stronger, with immediate responses like "stop using them just in case" being prominent.


(B) Skeptical/Wait-and-See Group
On the other hand, there are voices asking, "How much transfers?" and "Is there a lot of actual harm?" While understanding that there is no zero risk, they relativize it by including other sources of exposure in daily life (living environment, food, hobbies) and take a stance of "not being overly afraid."


(C) Practical/Countermeasure Group
And increasing are those who want to "test and decide," "find ways to use them," and "avoid acidic dishes." On English-speaking boards, suggestions like "check with a test kit" and "avoid sour foods" are repeatedly made. There is an atmosphere of balancing effort and safety rather than taking extreme measures.


These three categories are actually very healthy. Right after information is released, anxiety comes first, then questions arise, and finally, it falls into specific measures. Social media visualizes this process.

8) So, What to Do Starting Today? Checklist

Finally, let's summarize the "practical steps" to avoid ending with just fear.

  • Be Aware of the Age: Especially old ceramics from the early 20th century to around 1950 are likely to be a topic of concern.

  • Avoid Acidic Foods: Tomatoes, vinegar, citrus, fruit juice, wine, etc., are not compatible with old dishes.

  • Reduce Frequency: Change usage from daily use to decoration, photography, or as a small item holder.

  • Be More Cautious in Households with Children: Growth periods are said to be more susceptible to effects, so prioritize household rules.

  • "Decide After Testing" is Also an Option: Although it costs money, it is rational for those who want a clear answer.


Vintage tableware is also a culture that enriches life. That's why, instead of rushing with just romance, it's important to skillfully determine the distance with information. That might be the most mature way to enjoy it.


Reference URLs

Related Articles