Skip to main content
ukiyo journal - 日本と世界をつなぐ新しいニュースメディア Logo
  • All Articles
  • 🗒️ Register
  • 🔑 Login
    • 日本語
    • 中文
    • Español
    • Français
    • 한국어
    • Deutsch
    • ภาษาไทย
    • हिंदी
Cookie Usage

We use cookies to improve our services and optimize user experience. Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy for more information.

Cookie Settings

You can configure detailed settings for cookie usage.

Essential Cookies

Cookies necessary for basic site functionality. These cannot be disabled.

Analytics Cookies

Cookies used to analyze site usage and improve our services.

Marketing Cookies

Cookies used to display personalized advertisements.

Functional Cookies

Cookies that provide functionality such as user settings and language selection.

Is It Unstoppable? The Tipping Point of Antarctica and Humanity's Choices - The Staircase Collapse Beyond "1.5°C"

Is It Unstoppable? The Tipping Point of Antarctica and Humanity's Choices - The Staircase Collapse Beyond "1.5°C"

2025年11月08日 11:56

1. From "Anomaly" to "Abrupt Change"—The Big Picture Painted by Cutting-Edge Research

On November 6, ScienceDaily released an article titled "Antarctica's Collapse May Already Be Unstoppable." The article was based on a review by an international team published in Nature in August, which organized evidence of simultaneous "abrupt changes" occurring in Antarctica and delved into their interactions. The key points are: ① a regime shift in sea ice (abnormal decrease beyond natural variability), ② slowdown of deep ocean circulation (Antarctic overturn), ③ destabilization of ice shelves and ice sheets, and ④ crossing of ecological thresholds. These are interconnected through "amplification loops." For instance, a decrease in sea ice makes the ocean surface more prone to heat absorption, leading to the intrusion of warm coastal waters, which in turn accelerates the melting of ice shelves from below and the outflow of ice sheets. ScienceDaily


2. West Antarctic Ice Sheet: A Critical Point That May Be Surpassed Even in the Best Scenario

The review warns that the "critical point of irreversible loss" of the **West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) may be exceeded even under the best emission reduction pathways. If WAIS collapses in the long term, the global average sea level could rise by more than 3 meters. Even if this occurs on a "centuries to millennia scale," it could serve as a "trigger" for accelerating sea level rise this century. Past studies on ice sheet dynamics have also shown that the intrusion of warm ocean water can self-sustain the retreat through **marine ice sheet instability (MISI). dx.doi.org


3. "Regime Shift" in Sea Ice and the Slowdown of the Ocean's "Blood Flow"

In recent years, Antarctic sea ice has repeatedly recorded extremely low levels, even by historical standards, described as a **"regime shift beyond the range of natural variability."** The decrease in sea ice lowers the albedo, further warming the ocean and promoting the slowdown of Antarctic overturn circulation. When circulation weakens, nutrients are less likely to upwell to the surface, reducing carbon absorption and ecosystem productivity, with negative impacts spreading from organisms to the climate. dx.doi.org


4. Penguins and Krill—Ecosystems Losing Their "Footing" and "Sustenance"

The early breakup of sea ice has caused breeding failures of emperor penguins in various regions. Satellite image analysis has confirmed years when chicks were almost entirely wiped out across regions. There are also concerns about significant declines in krill and some penguin and seal species, as well as the weakening of the phytoplankton base. The crisis facing living organisms also affects fishery resources and carbon cycles. ScienceDaily


5. The Collapse of the "Ice Gate" Progressing Simultaneously

On November 6, news also emerged about the latest research tracking how the ice shelf of the Thwaites Glacier (known as the "last bastion of Earth") has been damaged and disintegrated over the past 20 years. The ice shelf acts as a "gatekeeper" for ice sheet outflow. When it becomes more prone to breaking, the inland ice's slide accelerates. It was a day when the news aligned with the overall picture painted by the review. UM Today


6. Reactions on Social Media: Researchers' Sense of Crisis, Institutional Awareness, and Distance from "Doomers"

On X (formerly Twitter), polar researchers and institutional accounts summarized the points of the review, spreading the terms "sea ice regime shift," "WAIS criticality," and "ocean circulation slowdown". For example, WCRP's climate and cryosphere program and Antarctic researchers' accounts explained the "mutually amplifying abrupt changes" with accompanying charts from the paper. In contrast, there were a few skeptical mentions like "the critical point is exaggerated" or "it's still uncertain." On bulletin boards, Reddit's climate-related threads saw discussions grow about the chain reaction of sea ice and ocean currents and implications for coastal cities. In the comment sections of scientific media, some pointed out the uncertainty of expressions like "could/may." Meanwhile, Australian media and Reuters reported that "the decline in sea ice is a 'sign of criticality,'" emphasizing that researchers themselves stress **"criticality may be exceeded even in the best case." While there is a risk of the discussion leaning towards "doom" (doomer), the climate research community maintains a stance of simultaneously conveying " the room to avoid the worst and concrete adaptation measures." X (formerly Twitter)


7. "So What Will We Change?"—Translation into Practice

(1) Japan's Coastal and Urban Infrastructure
Long-term sea level rise is inevitable. There is a need to reevaluate levee heights, design for compound hazards of storm surges and uprisings, and build redundancy in coastal supply chains (ports, warehouses, power generation, IT hubs). Check against the worst-case scenario of **"gradual acceleration this century"** and proceed in tandem with land use regulations and relocation plans. dx.doi.org


(2) Industry, Finance, and Insurance
Ice sheet risk is a "fat-tailed risk." Within decades, there could be a reorganization of insurance premium rates and port relocations in international supply chains. It is essential to disclose and allocate capital for not only the "transition" but also the "physical"** risks in climate-related financial disclosures (TCFD/ISSB). dx.doi.org


(3) Ocean, Ecosystems, and Food
The slowdown of nutrient supply originating from Antarctica can also affect primary production in distant marine areas. Fisheries management should shift to "dynamic management" linked with predictions of sea temperature, sea ice, and wind fields. International negotiations over krill fishing regulations in the Southern Ocean should also be closely monitored. dx.doi.org


(4) Simultaneous Execution of Emission Reductions and Adaptation
The review clearly states that " minimizing the exceedance of 1.5°C is essential for suppressing abrupt change chains." However, to **nip the "seeds of irreversibility" in the bud, advancing adaptation** (coastal planning, flood response, health risks, evacuation planning) is also necessary. dx.doi.org


8. Three Common Misunderstandings (Fact Check)

  • "Antarctica has always fluctuated"
    → That's true, but the **recent decline and continuity are being organized as "outside the range of natural variability."** The expression regime shift is used for that reason. dx.doi.org

  • "The sea level won't rise by 3 meters immediately"
    → Correct. Ice sheet collapse is a long-term process, but it is a "switch" that can accelerate the rate of rise this century. dx.doi.org

  • "Ecosystems will adapt, so it's okay"
    → There are already regions where breeding failures of emperor penguins have been observed. Crossing thresholds doesn't necessarily mean a "return to normal." Nature


9. Conclusion—Towards an Era of "Choice" Rather Than "Reduction"

Today's message is simple. The icy continent is no longer a distant event. The "amplification loop" connecting ice, sea, organisms, and society has begun to move. What remains for us are not three choices of ① reduction (getting as close to 1.5°C as possible), ② adaptation (implementing ahead of schedule), and ③ resilience investment (preparing for the worst). It is to do all three simultaneously. Science is not for pessimism, but for decision-making. dx.doi.org



References: Reports and Primary Information

  • Summary of ScienceDaily (released on 11/6) and original press information (ANU) ScienceDaily

  • Nature Review (published on 8/20, abstract and figures) dx.doi.org

  • Breeding Failure of Emperor Penguins (Satellite Observations in 2023) Nature

  • New Report on Thwaites Glacier Ice Shelf Damage (11/6) UM Today

  • International Coverage of the Review by Reuters (8/20) Reuters


Reference Articles

Scientists Warn Antarctica's Collapse May Already Be Unstoppable
Source: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2025/11/251106003941.htm

Powered by Froala Editor##

← Back to Article List

Contact |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Cookie Policy |  Cookie Settings

© Copyright ukiyo journal - 日本と世界をつなぐ新しいニュースメディア All rights reserved.