Designing Uncertainty - Outmaneuvering Heisenberg: Quantum Sensors Unlocked by Modular Measurement

Live Science on September 28, 2025, with the provocative headline "A 'Loophole' in Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle," does not actually violate the principle. The research team used modular observables, focusing only on the "remainders" at regular intervals rather than the "absolute values" of position and momentum, to successfully read minute changes simultaneously from the motion of a single ion (a single atom). The paper was published on September 24 in Science Advances, and the experiment was led by the Quantum Control Laboratory at the University of Sydney. Live ScienceScience

What was measured "simultaneously"

The usual uncertainty principle asserts that the product of the variances of position $x$ and momentum $p$ cannot be less than $\hbar/2$. Here, the team measured not $x$ or $p$ themselves, but only the "deviation from the scale markings" (modular position/modular momentum). The idea is to discard the overall "which centimeter you are in" and keep only "how many millimeters you are from the last marking." By intentionally discarding overall information, the precision of the necessary parts is significantly enhanced. Live Science

The key to this strategy is the grid state (GKP lattice state). The quantum state of the trapped ion is shaped like a lattice with evenly spaced peaks. When a force is applied, the entire lattice "slides" or "tilts," manifesting as small changes in both position and momentum—this is why changes in both can be read simultaneously. Live Science

How sensitive was it?

The force sensitivity achieved was about 10 yoctonewtons ($10^{-23}$ N). While not a world record, the significance lies in reaching this domain with a single atom and relatively simple apparatus. It points the way to "small and smart" quantum sensors without relying on large oscillators or extensive equipment. Live Science

What is "new" & "not breaking"?

A common misunderstanding is that "measuring simultaneously = breaking the principle." The quantities being measured are different from the conventional ones (modular quantities), so the research team explains it as redistributing the "air in the uncertainty 'balloon'" to unnecessary areas. This achievement is positioned as an extension of the trend of **"smart measurement within the framework of the principle,"** such as weak measurements and the reformulation of error-disturbance relations (Ozawa's inequality) in the 2010s. The University of SydneyarXiv

Applications Impact: From GPS-independent measurement to medical and space

The research team and derivative reports cite applications such as navigation in environments where GPS is unavailable like underground, underwater, and space, next-generation atomic clocks, non-invasive medical imaging, and material and gravity measurement. The key point is that this is not a "silver bullet" to replace existing methods, but rather a new driver added to the quantum sensing toolbox. The University of Sydney

Academic Positioning

The idea of using modular variables and lattice states builds on a foundation of theoretical and experimental work (e.g., prior experiments from 2017–2018). The contribution of this study lies in demonstrating simultaneous estimation of multiple variables (position & momentum) in a single mode, stepping beyond the "standard quantum limit." arXiv+2Physical Review

SNS Reactions: Buzz over "Breaking Bad" References and Serious Discussion

• On Reddit's /r/science, threads via university releases included summaries like **"It's not breaking the laws of physics, just cleverly 'bending' them," and jokes referencing the show 'Breaking Bad' such as "I am the uncertainty!". Meanwhile, there were also serious comments drawing parallels to high-precision measurements like those of LIGO, creating an atmosphere of both expectation and humor.Reddit

• Tech media and news aggregators widely quoted the university's explanations ("balloon air" metaphor and grid state), spreading it as the **"foundation for next-generation quantum sensors."** ScienceDaily

Common Misunderstandings and Correct Understanding (3-line Points)

• Misunderstanding: "Simultaneously knowing the 'exact values' of position and momentum" → Correctly: "Simultaneously estimated modular changes with high precision."Live Science

• Misunderstanding: "Denial of the uncertainty principle" → Correctly: "Reallocation of uncertainty, just changed the 'way of measuring.'"The University of Sydney

• Misunderstanding: "Immediate practical use" → Correctly: "Research stage. However, the significance of demonstrating high sensitivity with a small and simple setup is great."Live Science

Basic Information of the Research

• Paper: Valahu et al., "Quantum-enhanced multiparameter sensing in a single mode," Science Advances 11:eadw9757 (Published on September 24, 2025). PDF also available.Science

• University Release (September 25): "Precision Sensing that Circumvents the Uncertainty Principle." Includes metaphors and diagrams.The University of Sydney

• General Reporting (September 28): Live Science's explanation. Includes grid state and sensitivity of about $10^{-23}$ N, with comments from Valahu.Live Science

Powered by Froala Editor